Settlement Talks Underway in Contentious Westerly Shoreline Access Case

Watch Hill Fire District challenges public right-of-way to Napatree Point; town council president faces backlash as shoreline advocates fear loss of public access

An access way to Napatree Point along Watch Hill Cove is pictured in this image from 2022.
An access way to Napatree Point along Watch Hill Cove is pictured in this image from 2022.
Alex Nunes/The Public’s Radio
Share
An access way to Napatree Point along Watch Hill Cove is pictured in this image from 2022.
An access way to Napatree Point along Watch Hill Cove is pictured in this image from 2022.
Alex Nunes/The Public’s Radio
Settlement Talks Underway in Contentious Westerly Shoreline Access Case
Copy

Settlement talks are ongoing between the town of Westerly and a shoreline fire district that wants a judge to invalidate a town-designated public right-of-way to the beach.

The Watch Hill Fire District is objecting to the town’s 2008 resolution to designate the Fort Road right-of-way. Beachgoers use the path to walk onto Napatree Point beach and conservation area.

Advocates for shoreline access are concerned that a potential settlement could threaten the public’s ability to use the beach in the future. Westerly town councilor Dylan LaPietra says he also has concerns about how the settlement talks have gone so far.

“I’m not optimistic,’ said LaPietra. ‘I’m not excited about the lack of representation of the rights-of-way people in the process.”

Westerly Town Council President Chris Duhamel has drawn the ire of access advocates who say he’s trying to circumvent a charter provision that prevents the town from abandoning its rights-of-way to the shoreline. They plan to present a petition to hold a recall vote on him at Monday night’s council meeting.

In an email, Duhamel told The Public’s Radio any legal settlement in the case would allow the public continued access to Napatree Point.

LaPietra says don’t expect a settlement anytime soon.

“I still think there’s plenty of time,” said LaPietra. “I think the public has this perception that it’s going to get voted on Monday night in executive session. I don’t think we’re that far along yet. I think there’s time to change. I’m maybe mildly concerned at this point.”

Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha is also involved in the case, representing the state Department of Environmental Management. His office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

DiPrete led Rhode Island through a period of economic growth in the 1980s, but his legacy was marred by a bribery and extortion scandal that made him the only governor in state history to serve time in prison
From cancer labs to coastal climate tools, Rhode Island researchers join scientists nationwide in warning that federal funding cuts could stall lifesaving work
T.F. Green received a score of 84.9 in the annual Travel + Leisure magazine competition based on reader surveys evaluating airport amenities
The hospital allowed an unlicensed medical assistant to do a procedure prohibited under state regulations
Famiglietti, a personal injury lawyer who serves on North Providence’s town council, won more than 70% of the district’s votes in a four-way race
A rare legal clash between the Justice Department and the federal judiciary echoes to Rhode Island, where a 1990s-era lawsuit filed by then–U.S. Attorney Sheldon Whitehouse offers precedent and underscores the escalating tensions between executive power and judicial independence